May 28, 2025
Last night, over 4,000 Harvard alumnae came together on a “Call to Arms” Zoom call to discuss what the Trump administration is trying to do to Harvard and higher education, and what you can do about it. The guiding philosophy of the Trump administration is “ yes, we know, but what are you going to do about it?” Harvard has taken a stand on behalf of itself, it’s alumnae, it’s faculty, it’s researchers, it’s international students, and it’s employees. As President Alan Garber said in his second Commencement Address, “The best way to acknowledge Harvard — and what this time has meant to you — is to advocate for education. Everything we might achieve — morally, scientifically, technologically, and even economically — is grounded in knowledge. Where else are you more likely to find a path to knowledge and all that it unlocks for humanity than in education?”
Harvard has had to endure an endless and mindless barrage of attacks from the federal government. Research grants have been rescinded, international students have been threatened, federal contracts have been terminated all under the guise of fighting anti-semitism. The potential harm to Harvard is in the billions of dollars. As many speakers pointed out, this has absolutely nothing to do with dealing with anti-semitism on campus. Harvard, like many educational institutions, started taking steps over a year ago to correct flaws in the system. Rather, this has everything to do with trying to destroy an institution that would not kowtow to Trump’s baseless claims and demands. If Trump were truly interested in fighting anti-semitism, this is not how one would go about it. Anti-semitism is a Trojan horse for controlling free speech and intellectual curiosity to make way for a radically conservative, Project 2025 agenda, whose aim it is to control thought and speech.
The call was moderated by noted syndicated columnist, a son of Fall River, and Harvard alumnus, E.J. Dionne. He made the point that Harvard should be flattered and honored that Trump has decided to make Harvard an example. Autocrats attempt to take down the lead dog in an industry, whether it be in education, the media, the law and so on as they wage their fake wars, believing that, if they can get the top entity to acquiesce, it would only be a matter of time before every other entity took a knee. Harvard is literally taking one for the higher education team. Legal experts on the call believed that the attacks on Harvard are baseless, frivolous, and without legal merit and will be turned aside by the courts, but damage will have been done, and that is the point. Endless lawsuits are a drain on time and financial resources.
However, if you feel that you don’t have a dog in this fight, or worse, you are quietly happy that those snarky, snot-nosed people at Harvard had it coming, think again. Maura Healy, Governor of Massachusetts and Harvard alumna, discussed the impact that the Trump attacks will have on the state of Massachusetts. For starters, Harvard is the fourth largest employer in the state. As Harvard goes, so goes the state. Federal cuts could set off a wave of unemployment that goes well beyond Harvard. Cuts could blow a hole in the Massachusetts economy that would have to be made up in other ways, be it higher taxes, reduced services, and less funding to local communities. The state would see its unemployment expenses rise. Unemployment affects housing. If demand is reduced, prices go down, and houses remain empty. Restaurants go out of business. Fenway Park is half full.
Harvard is the greatest intellectual engine in the world. People come here from all over the world to study, do research, and start companies. Companies hire people, and pay taxes. There are already signs that many of these students are making plans to study overseas, and take their creative and entrepreneurial talents with them because they no longer feel comfortable here. Who could blame them as ICE agents scoop up international students? Without this engine of intellectual growth, Massachusetts becomes, I dare say, Florida.
Harvard alumnae have been asked to open their wallets. Many alumnae, who felt Harvard already had too much money and/or didn’t agree with some of its policies, are giving for the first time in years. I have spoken to non-alumnae who have made contributions because they believe this battle for the soul of higher education is that important. Alumnae and other others need to make themselves heard either through peaceful protest, contacting their elected representatives, writing letters to the editor, voting, and writing opinion pieces for local newspapers. Trump may have poked the bear.